Our analysis shows that this voting system is far below even the most minimal security standards applicable in other contexts. Security analysis of the estonian internet voting system drew springall travis finkenauer zakir durumeric jason kitcat harri hursti margaret macalpine j. Security analysis of indias electronic voting machines. Following the survey, an analysis is performed on the cases with a number of conclusions drawn. Evaluating electronic voting systems equipped with voterverified. The key issue that is unique to electronic voting is the interaction between those. This paper includes analysis of the security and auditing mechanisms of the opensource electronic voting system scantegrity. Department of defenses fvap federal voting assistance program. Electronic voting challenges and opportunities published by. This november, at least 80 percent of registered voters will make selections on a paper ballot, or vote on an electronic machine that produces a paper trail. To vote for a candidate, voters only need to press on the keyboard the number designated for a particular candidate. Read this essay on analysis of an electronic voting system.
Pdf analysis of an electronic voting system oguntade. One company even offers an electronic voting system designed for use by disabled voters hart intercivic 2001. Where possible, each case includes a description of the technologies used, the reasons for implementing electronic voting, and any major problems encountered. Voting system security and reliability risks brennan center for. Voters in brazil use an electronic voting device that, for each office, displays the choices and prompts the voter for his or her vote. Analysis of an electronic boardroom voting system loria.
Like many democracies, india is striving to modernise and streamline its voting system through the adoption of electronic technology. Estimate for the cost of replacing paperless, computerized. A security analysis of the secure electronic registration and. The first pays special attention to the three large municipalities within canada that have conducted internet voting pilot.
Electronic voting refers to any system where a voter casts his or her ballot using an electronic system, rather than a paper ballot or mechanical mach ine to punch a paper ballot. In this technological and knowledge age, ecommerce related matters become popular. We suggest that the best solutions are voting systems having a voterveri. Teaching case analysis of an electronic voting system. It interacted with the user via an integrated touchscreen lcd display. The national committee didnt completely get out of the traditional voting system.
An electronic voting system can be involved in any one of a number of steps in the setup, distributing, voting, collecting, and counting of ballots, and thus may or may not introduce advantages into any of these steps. New jerseys criteria against several different e voting machine types revealed potential threatsand possible solutionson. This paper provides an overview of the experiences of other countries using electronic. Electronic voting is one of these matters and it is able to provide convenient, less expensive, fast and secure facilities. These lecture notes survey some of the main ideas and techniques used in cryptographic voting systems.
Electronic voting systems may offer advantages compared to other voting techniques. In the following years, the number of people able to use electronic voting grew as more and more cantons began adopting such a system. While most existing systems rely on opaque electronic devices, a scienti. Experiments and data analysis of electronic voting system komminist weldemariam1,2 1dept. Consider the importance of introducing an electronic system from a democratic. Estonia has had electronic voting since 2005 and in 2007 was the first country in the world to. This specification design document will detail the design of an electronic voting system for the state of maryland.
Jul 28, 2012 their report even proposes aframework for a new voting system with a decentralized, modular design. A security analysis of the swiss electronic voting system. Cost analysis of marylands electronic voting system. Internally, electronic voting systems have many functions, including encryption, randomization, communication and security systems. The design of a good voting system, whether electronic or using. Analysis of an electronic voting system term paper. Keywords electronic voting systems, direct recording electronic dre, voting usability. Security analysis of scantegrity, an electronic voting system. Pdf experiments and data analysis of electronic voting. The voting machines feature an integrated screen and keyboard. Analysis must include the following costs beyond the price of equipment.
As has been discussed previously in this manual, the successful implementation of electronic voting. Analysis of an electronic voting system request pdf. Hence the system couldnt cut down the cost rather there was an upsurge in the cost as they are conducting both the e voting session and the traditional voting system. First, observe that electronic banking is not perfectly secure. Analysis of electronic voting system implemented in various countries in electronic voting 2, rivest addresses some issues like the secure platform 2 problem and the impossibility of giving a receipt to the voter.
Hence the system couldnt cut down the cost rather there was an upsurge in the cost as they are conducting both the evoting session and the traditional voting system. Analysis of an electronic boardroom voting system springerlink. While electronic voting certainly has advantages over paper voting. In the analysis of an electronic voting system paper by 17 there is a fear raised about a possibility of a man in the middle attack which results into the theft of electronic data as it. Introduction a major lesson derived from the 2000 presidential election. A security analysis of the swiss electronic voting system author andrea baumann 05533971 daniela haberli 08211666 department. Security analysis of the estonian internet voting system.
A costbenefit analysis of electronic voting operations. Our analysis shows these systems work well, but have several problems, and a significant minority of voters have concerns about them. The key issue that is unique to electronic voting is the interaction between those requirements. Analysis of an electronic voting system ieee conference.
Come browse our large digital warehouse of free sample essays. Meier suggests that evoting implies a lower personal involvement of the voter than the eelection. Still there is some scope of work in electronic voting system because there is no way of identification by the electronic voting system whether the user is authentic or not and securing electronic voting machine from miscreants. The writeup is geared towards readers with little knowledge of cryptography and it focuses on. We present a security analysis of the source code to one such machine used in a signi. This paper provides an overview of the experiences of other countries using electronic voting machine. Any paperless electronic voting system might suffer similar flaws, despite any certification it could have otherwise received.
The comparative focus is on the adoption of electronic voting systems adopted at the international level. Experiments and data analysis of electronic voting system. Digital voting with the use of blockchain technology. Analysis of conventional and electronic voting systems. Diebold controversy since 2003 when code leaked on internet. A document analysis system for supporting electronic voting. Bungale and swaroop sridhar department of computer science the johns hopkins university i functional requirements 1. Analysis of electronic voting system in various countries mr. While most existing systems rely on opaque electronic devices, a scientific committee of a. Design, analysis and deployment in most respects, the accuvotets was a prototypical dre. Design and implementation of an electronic voting system.
Typical features and functionalities of e voting systems internally, electronic voting systems have many functions, including encryption, randomization, communication and security systems. Analysis of an electronic voting system rather than respond with a 35 page point by point rebuttal and risk a continuously growing exchange, we focus on a few examples of diebolds misinformation, and we show some examples of security. Finally, it recommends strategies for achievi ng political development, leadership accountability, responsible governance, and sustainable democracies in africa. Implementing and overseeing electronic voting and counting. Denialofservice dos attacks interrupt or slow access to computer systems. A security analysis of the secure electronic registration. Analysis of an electronic voting system ieee xplore.
E voting sticker shock since converting to a statewide electronic touchscreen voting system, marylands election costs have soared. While the introduction of internet voting in the u. For additional materials and contact information, visit. May 26, 2012 voting systems, municipalities and states throughout the u. Properly implemented, evoting solutions can increase the security of the ballot, speed up the processing of results and make voting. Click here for democracy a comparative analysis of. We study a simple electronic boardroom voting system. Our analysis shows that this voting system is far below. Implementation and analysis of secure electronic voting system htet ne oo, aye moe aung abstract. Every poll site statewide will have identical architectures. The development of the case was motivated by research into information security and management, but as it includes procedural aspects, organizational structure and personnel, it is a suitable basis for all aspects of systems analysis, planning and design tasks. This electronic voting system will enable a valid voter to vote at any polling site statewide during an election period. We therefore analyzed the helios remote electronic voting system described in 3.
Since people in different countries are using digital technology in the voting process e. Get the knowledge you need in order to pass your classes and more. A guide to conducting feasibility studies about the author ben goldsmith is a senior electoral advisor with over 10 years of experience advising and managing election administration projects in postconflict and developing democracies. Ballot casting, recording, and tabulation are routinely done with computers even in voting systems that are not, strictly speaking, electronic. As well as that, while a paperbased audit trail may be possible with an e voting system, such an. Electoral commission report concluded that the implementation and security risk wassigni cant and unacceptableand recommends that no further e voting take placeuntil a su ciently secure and transparent system is available. Gao was requested to 1 determine the significant security and reliability concerns identified about electronic voting systems. While most existing systems rely on opaque electronic devices, a scientific committee of a research. If the seal is not clear enough, or the vote is damaged by soiling, it may bring some debate on the result. The voter should not be restricted to cast his ballot at a single pollsite at his home precinct. We now spend nearly 10 times as much to conduct our elections as we did just 7 years ago. Abstract in the netherlands as well as many other countries, the use of electronic voting solutions is a recurrent topic of discussion. The study looks at e voting technologies against the manual paper based voting systems and does not look at a specific e voting technology system.
The study also looks at the factors that could influence the adoption of electronic voting. A specific analysis of these functionalities goes beyond the immediate scope of this paper. Electronic voting in the strict sense is a system where the first step, ballot composition or choosing, is done with the aid of a computer. This teaching case discusses the analysis of an electronic voting system. The introduction of electronic voting and counting systems makes them even more complex. Request pdf analysis of an electronic voting system with significant u. With these considerations, the usability of such e2e veri. Design and implementation of an electronic voting system with contactless ic cards abstract in the past, people go to polling place and take the blank ballots, then punch a hole or append the seal. However, reported problems with electronic voting systems have led to questions about the security and reliability of these systems. An election or referendum that involves the use of electronic means in at least the casting of the vote coe 2011d, p. Many democracies rely on evoting systems for binding elections, whether for in.
Requirements for an electronic voting system prashanth p. Alex halderman university of michigan, ann arbor, mi, u. Cryptographic voting a gentle introduction david bernhard and bogdan warinschi university of bristol, england abstract. For a basic understanding of what e voting systems can do, however, it is useful to consider the following list of. This case discusses the analysis of an electronic voting system. Other researchers have done work in electronic voting. We focus on scantegrity, not to single it out as a vulnerable system, but because it is a popular system that has actually been used in practice. This was the first trial of e voting in switzerland.
711 555 989 495 282 935 1548 1373 1517 1432 393 1600 1069 124 1145 1417 1330 667 905 531 1131 1109 1396 819 1093 223 649 222 393